Monday’s primary election held few surprises, although several races and contested issues were slightly closer than projected.

The most closely watched local campaign was for GA House District 2. Incumbent Steve Tarvin (first elected in January) faced challengers EBeth Edwards and Rebecca Ann Brown. Tarvin soundly defeated both challengers with 65.88% of the 4,039 votes cast. With no Democrat candidate to face in November, Rep. Tarvin will go back to Atlanta for an additional two years.
Tarvin took a majority of votes in all three counties involved and also won every single voting precinct except Edwards’ home precinct of Armuchee/Villanow. And even there as many people voted for her opponents (10 and 97 respectively) as voted for her (107). Half the people who know Edwards apparently know better than to vote for her; Hopefully this means her political aspirations are done.
PRECINCT BY PRECINCT RESULTS / HOUSE DISTRICT 2:
PRECINCT |
BROWN |
EDWARDS |
TARVIN (I) |
TOTAL |
ARMUCHEE |
10 |
107 |
97 |
214 |
BLACKSTOCK (Catoosa) |
13 |
28 |
92 |
133 |
CENTER POST |
13 |
42 |
78 |
133 |
CHAMBERS (Catoosa) |
25 |
62 |
188 |
275 |
CHICKAMAUGA |
51 |
109 |
539 |
699 |
LAFAYETTE |
70 |
232 |
385 |
687 |
ROCK SPRING |
81 |
163 |
512 |
756 |
TRICHUM (Whitfield) |
20 |
48 |
114 |
182 |
TUNNEL HILL (Whitfield) |
43 |
64 |
249 |
356 |
WESTSIDE (Whitfield) |
51 |
47 |
241 |
339 |
WOODSTATION (Catoosa) |
29 |
70 |
166 |
265 |
TOTAL VOTES |
406 (10.05%) |
972 (24.07%) |
2,661 (65.88%) |
4,039 |
Incumbent John Deffenbaugh (R-Addams Family) didn’t fare as well in State House District 1. He won the race but received less than half the total votes cast for his opponents, Robert Goff of Dade and Alan Painter of Walker. Deffenbaugh, who lives in Dade, won all but one Walker County precinct, while Goff (who also lives in Dade) won every Dade precinct. Alan Painter claimed victory in just one of the fifteen contested areas, but was only 26 votes shy of tying Goff’s total.
A runoff vote for this race, Deffenbaugh vs. Goff, will be held in July; the winner of that election will still have to face Democrat candidate Tom McMahan in November.
PRECINCT BY PRECINCT RESULTS / HOUSE DISTRICT 1:
PRECINCT |
DEFFENBAUGH (I) |
GOFF |
PAINTER |
TOTAL |
CENTER POST |
38 |
8 |
20 |
66 |
CHATT VALLEY |
278 |
53 |
232 |
563 |
CHICKAMAUGA |
114 |
28 |
86 |
228 |
DAVIS (Dade) |
74 |
134 |
56 |
264 |
FAIRVIEW |
111 |
28 |
46 |
185 |
FAIRYLAND |
127 |
9 |
14 |
150 |
KENSINGTON |
56 |
12 |
67 |
135 |
MOUNTAIN |
54 |
16 |
39 |
109 |
NEW HOME (Dade) |
28 |
63 |
19 |
110 |
N SALEM (Dade) |
52 |
70 |
56 |
178 |
NO DADE (Dade) |
69 |
105 |
50 |
224 |
ROSSVILLE |
272 |
52 |
119 |
443 |
SO DADE (Dade) |
36 |
83 |
20 |
139 |
TRENTON (Dade) |
93 |
244 |
60 |
397 |
WS BROW (Dade) |
117 |
36 |
31 |
184 |
TOTAL VOTES |
1,519 (45.01%) |
941 (27.88%) |
915 (27.11%) |
3,375 |
Ten-year-incumbent State Senator Jeff Mullis of Chickamauga (R-Georgia Power) easily beat his opponent, Tom Dooley of LaFayette. Mullis claimed victory in every precinct of Walker, Dade, Catoosa, and Chattooga so for the sake of time and space there will be no precinct-by-precinct breakdown of that vote here.
Mullis’ 68.51% margin over Dooley looks like a crushing defeat for the political newcomer, but considering Mullis’ half-million-dollar campaign fund and Dooley’s few hundred dollars, Dooley’s 31% should be considered a victory. Final reports on campaign spending haven’t been released, but it’s very likely Mullis spent several hundred times the money Tom did to get only twice as many votes.
Mullis has no Democrat opponent and will retain his position at the Atlanta feeding trough for another two winters.
COUNTY BY COUNTY RESULTS / SENATE DISTRICT 53:
COUNTY |
DOOLEY |
MULLIS |
TOTAL |
CATOOSA |
970 |
2,204 |
3,174 |
CHATTOOGA |
366 |
876 |
1,242 |
DADE |
476 |
967 |
1,443 |
WALKER |
1,407 |
2,957 |
4,364 |
TOTAL VOTES |
3,219 (31.49%) |
7,004 (68.51%) |
10,223 |
State-wide, Governor Nathan Deal defeated HIS two primary opponents, John Barge and David Pennington, with a large margin, over 70%. Georgia voters, like most in Walker County, are apparently willing to ignore ethical problems and corruption to go with a familiar name. Deal will face Democrat Jason Carter in November.
STATE-WIDE RESULTS / GA GOVERNOR:
BARGE |
DEAL |
PENNINGTON |
TOTAL |
65,312 (11.17%) |
421,672 (72.11%) |
97,813 (16.73%) |
584,797 |
Here in Walker only two local issues were being decided: A .25 mil property tax to support libraries, and a measure ceding control of alcohol regulations in the county to Commissioner Heiskell.
Alcohol control (promoted as allowing liquor sales in the county, but that’s not guaranteed) was approved by 56% of voters, winning all but one of the eleven precincts. The library tax was rejected, with 53% of voters saying no. Two of the four precincts that supported a tax for the library (Chickamauga and Rossville) actually have libraries; LaFayette was the only area with a standing library to reject the idea of supporting it.
As the Walker County Messenger appropriately summarized, “Walker County voters say yes to booze, no to books.” (There’s your new county slogan.)
PRECINCT BY PRECINCT RESULTS / ALCOHOL & LIBRARY:
PRECINCT |
ALCOHOL YES |
ALC TOTAL |
|
LIBRARY YES |
LIB TOTAL |
ARMUCHEE |
134 (56.78%) |
236 |
|
84 (35.44%) |
237 |
CENTER POST |
119 (50.85%) |
234 |
|
95 (40.08%) |
237 |
CHATT VALLEY |
384 (53.78%) |
714 |
|
334 (46.98%) |
711 |
CHICKAMAUGA |
625 (59.64%) |
1,048 |
|
528 (51.01%) |
1,035 |
FAIRVIEW |
113 (46.50%) |
243 |
|
122 (50.83%) |
240 |
FAIRYLAND |
147 (83.05%) |
177 |
|
93 (52.25%) |
178 |
KENSINGTON |
95 (51.63%) |
184 |
|
92 (49.73%) |
185 |
LAFAYETTE |
451 (55.20%) |
817 |
|
375 (45.73%) |
820 |
MOUNTAIN |
77 (56.20%) |
137 |
|
55 (39.86%) |
138 |
ROCK SPRING |
470 (54.71%) |
859 |
|
347 (40.35%) |
860 |
ROSSVILLE |
316 (56.13%) |
563 |
|
294 (52.50%) |
560 |
TOTAL VOTES |
2,931 (56.24%) |
5,212 |
|
2,419 (46.51%) |
5,201 |
Precincts approving the library tax might have less to do with having their own library and more to do with which voters trust the Commissioner to actually do what she said with the tax money. The same areas that backed the tax – Chickamauga, Fairview, Fairyland, Rossville – have also been the most supportive of Commissioner Heiskell during the last few elections and provided the greatest support to renewing SPLOST last year.
That theory of trust also makes sense after talking to several people who said they support libraries and would have voted for the tax except they don’t trust Heiskell to do what she said with the funds OR don’t want to expand taxes in light of how other tax money in the county has been used.
The same county that trusted Heiskell with the SPLOST tax (which costs each family several hundred dollars annually) last year now reject a library tax that would add $10 to their property tax bills.
Next Daily Update will take a closer look at voter turnout, or the lack thereof.

Read More >>